07/10/2026
Don’t you hate it when you give a recruiter a salary budget…
…and they send you candidates who want more?
The brief is the brief.
If a client sets a budget of $X, a recruiter’s job isn’t to continually present candidates at $Y and expect the business to find the extra money.
But occasionally, there’s a candidate who genuinely needs to be seen.
A recent management search was a perfect example.
There were two excellent candidates who matched the brief, including the salary expectations.
Then there was a third.
More experienced. More capable than the role required. And, yes, more expensive.
But understanding the client’s business, their ambitions and what they were trying to achieve made it clear that this candidate could potentially bring significantly more value to both the role and the wider business.
They could have been screened out simply because they were over budget.
But doing that would have removed the client’s opportunity to decide whether that additional value was worth paying for.
So all three candidates were presented.
The client was clear on why the third candidate sat outside the original brief, why they were still worth meeting and what they could potentially bring to the business beyond the role as it had initially been defined.
The client interviewed all three.
They hired the candidate who was over budget - and paid them what they wanted.
Not because the other two couldn’t do the job. They absolutely could.
But once the client had met all three, they could see the additional value the third candidate could bring beyond the original brief.
It raises an interesting question as salary transparency becomes increasingly common in job advertising.
Would that candidate have applied if they’d seen the advertised salary range?
Probably not.
And the business may never have known what it was missing.
Salary ranges matter. Recruitment briefs matter. Budgets matter.
But sometimes the best person for a business sits just outside the parameters that have been set.
That’s where good recruitment goes beyond matching CVs to job descriptions.
It’s about knowing the market, understanding the business and recognising when someone is worth putting in front of a client - even when they don’t tick every box on the original brief.
Because sometimes the question isn’t:
“Are they within budget?”
It’s:
“Are they worth it?”